Skip to content
Bennett Carroll Solicitors- Legal Problem Solvers- Queensland Lawyers - Header Logo
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Meet the Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Commercial & Business
      • Commercial & Business Law
      • Business Partnership Disputes
      • Building & Construction Law
    • Family Law
      • Family Law
      • Family Law Involving Business
    • Wills + Estates
      • Wills + Estates Overview
      • Wills + Planning
      • Managing an Estate
      • Will + Estate Disputes
    • Conveyancing
      • Conveyancing + Property Law
      • Real Estate Agents
    • Criminal + Litigation
      • Litigation
      • Criminal + Traffic Law
  • Resources
    • Advice + Articles
    • Free Legal Health Check
    • Toolkits & Guides
    • Help Choosing a Law Firm
    • 10 Awkward Questions
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Meet the Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Commercial & Business
      • Commercial & Business Law
      • Business Partnership Disputes
      • Building & Construction Law
    • Family Law
      • Family Law
      • Family Law Involving Business
    • Wills + Estates
      • Wills + Estates Overview
      • Wills + Planning
      • Managing an Estate
      • Will + Estate Disputes
    • Conveyancing
      • Conveyancing + Property Law
      • Real Estate Agents
    • Criminal + Litigation
      • Litigation
      • Criminal + Traffic Law
  • Resources
    • Advice + Articles
    • Free Legal Health Check
    • Toolkits & Guides
    • Help Choosing a Law Firm
    • 10 Awkward Questions
  • Contact Us
Advice & Articles

Small Businesses – Fake Reviews Can Close You Down – Legal Advice Article

  • Published: 23 August 2023
  • Last Updated: 22 May 2024

Small Businesses – Fake Reviews Can Close You Down

Don’t post fake reviews on your website – it could cost you your business.

 

Recently, the Federal Court fined Star Plus Group for faking online reviews. Star Plus Group an electrical, plumbing and gas fitting service company posted nearly 150 false testimonials on Yellow Pages website and productreview.com.au under false names. Star then claimed the 4.8 Yellow Pages rating on its website.

 

Star also falsified several invoices that “were addressed to fictitious individuals and were prepared and submitted to facilitate the misleading and deceptive conduct”. Judge Shaun Brendan McElwaine said that the conduct was “deliberate, sophisticated and well-planned” and that such favourable reviews unfairly advantaged Star.

 

The ACCC website page for Online Product and Service Reviews states:

  • It’s against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews or to arrange for others to do so;
  • Reviews encompass business’ website, social media or review platforms;
  • Reviews should be independent;
  • Reviews should reflect genuine opinion of the person who experienced the product or service;
  • Reviews cannot be edited or changed by someone else after being created;
  • Businesses cannot suppress, remove or edit negative reviews;
  • Businesses that offer incentives for positive reviews must clearly disclose how the review was incentivized.
  • If a business is concerned that a review platform has published a false or misleading review – they should contact the platform and request it be removed. Or they can correct the public record.

 

The ACCC can accept reports about fake/misleading reviews and can investigate further. It is worthwhile to read the page to ensure that your business complies with the guidelines.

 

In the end, the court ordered SPF (SA) to publish a notice on their website acknowledging its conduct, the Court’s finding and the fine.

The fine was $125K, can your business afford that?

 

Call us on 1300 334 566 or email info@bcglaw.com.au and safeguard your interests every step of the way- We are your legal problem solvers.

Small Businesses – Fake Reviews Can Close You Down - Legal Advice Article
Small Businesses – Fake Reviews Can Close You Down – legal advice article

 

Related Articles

: Expert legal advice for business owners and company directors across Australia, including Brisbane, Gold Coast, Sunshine Coast, and Sydney, on safeguarding company assets, private shares, and intellectual property. Specialised assistance in drafting Binding Financial Agreements (BFAs) to protect commercial interests against de facto relationship claims, marriage breakdowns, and family law property settlements. We provide comprehensive strategies for ring-fencing family trusts, discretionary structures, and startup equity, ensuring your business succession plan remains intact without the need for an office visit.

Protecting Your Business in a New Relationship: A National Guide for Entrepreneurs

Director Penalty Notices and Small Business Restructuring: What Queensland Directors Need to Know Before a Crisis Hits Understanding your ATO debt obligations and insolvency options early gives Queensland directors more control, not less. Practical legal guidance from Bennett Carroll Solicitors. The ATO issued more than 84,000 Director Penalty Notices in the last financial year alone. That is more than triple the year before. A DPN is not a warning letter. It is a mechanism that makes company tax debt your personal debt, sometimes permanently, and sometimes before you even open the envelope.

Director Penalty Notices and Small Business Restructuring: What Queensland Directors Need to Know Before a Crisis Hits

Navigating Business Contracts: How a Contract Lawyer Can Safeguard Your Interests

When Construction Companies Collapse: Understanding the Ripple Effects

Understanding Shareholder Disputes — Causes, Impacts & Early Warnings | Shareholder Disputes in Queensland Series- Part 1/5

Many Queensland business directors sign personal guarantees when securing finance, leasing property, or obtaining supplier credit. These guarantees can make you personally responsible for company debts — even risking your home or savings. This guide explains how personal guarantees work, when liability is triggered, your legal defences, and how to protect your personal assets. Learn when to seek urgent legal advice from Bennett Carroll Solicitors, Queensland commercial law specialists.

Director Personal Guarantees: When You’re Personally Liable for Business Debts

This information is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute specific or personal legal advice. Please consult with a qualified member of our team for advice regarding your specific situation.

PrevPreviousHelp Choosing a Law Firm
NextHow to Prepare for Your First Family Law Consultation in QueenslandNext
Serving Clients Across Queensland
Bennett Carroll Solicitors is a proud member of the Queensland Law Society (QLS)

Practice areas

  • Commercial + Business
  • Litigation
  • Family Law
  • Wills + Estates
  • Conveyancing
  • Building + Construction Law
  • Criminal + Traffic

learn more

  • About Us
  • Meet the Team
  • Advice + Articles
  • Contact Us
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Our Office Locations in SEQ - click to view

  • Brisbane North - Stafford
  • Brisbane South - Upper Mount Gravatt
  • Sunshine Coast - Kawana Waters
  • Gold Coast - Mermaid Beach
  • Ipswich- By Appointment Only
  • Brisbane Central- By Appointment Only

Get In Touch

  • 1300 334 566
  • Click to Email
  • 8.30am - 5pm Monday - Friday
  • Chat With Us (Bottom of this page)
  • Bennett Carroll Solicitors
  • 1300 334 566
Copyright 2025 © Bennett Carroll Solicitors | All rights reserved | Privacy Policy