For small business owners in Queensland, commercial leases are often one of the most important contractual relationships they enter. Whether you operate a retail shop in Brisbane’s CBD, a manufacturing facility in Townsville, or a professional office on the Gold Coast, your lease agreement sets the foundation for your rights and obligations regarding your business premises. Unfortunately, disputes over leases are common and can seriously affect your business operations, finances, and future plans.
This guide outlines the most common commercial lease disputes in Queensland and offers practical advice on how to manage these challenges effectively.
The Queensland Commercial Leasing Landscape
Commercial leasing in Queensland is governed by a mix of common law principles and statutory regulations. The main legislation for retail shop leases is the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), which provides extra protections for retail tenants. Non-retail commercial leases are generally governed by common law and the specific terms outlined in the lease.
Knowing which rules apply to your lease is crucial. Retail leases typically cover businesses in shopping centres and designated retail areas, while professional offices, industrial sites, and warehouses usually fall under standard commercial leases.
Common Commercial Lease Disputes in Queensland
1. Rent Review Disputes
Rent reviews are one of the most frequent causes of dispute. Queensland commercial leases usually include provisions for periodic rent reviews, which might be based on:
- Fixed percentage increases (e.g. 3% per year)
- Consumer Price Index (CPI) adjustments linked to inflation
- Market reviews adjusting rent to current market rates for similar premises
Disagreements often arise during market rent reviews, as landlords and tenants may have very different views on what “market rent” means. This is especially tricky for unique or specialised premises where there are few comparable properties.
Tips for Negotiating Rent Reviews:
- Research comparable properties in your area, considering location, size, and amenities.
- Understand the rent review clause in your lease, including caps or floors.
- Consider engaging a professional valuer for an independent assessment.
- Explore phased increases or temporary concessions if market conditions justify it.
- Keep detailed records of all rent discussions and agreements.
2. Maintenance and Repair Responsibilities
Disputes often arise over who is responsible for maintenance and repairs. Queensland commercial leases usually specify:
- Structural repairs (usually landlord’s responsibility)
- Non-structural maintenance (usually tenant’s responsibility)
- Common area maintenance costs
- Air conditioning, electrical, and plumbing systems
- Compliance with building codes and regulations
Ambiguous lease wording or unexpected major repairs can cause significant financial and operational headaches.
Preventing Maintenance Disputes:
- Conduct thorough entry condition reports with photos and expert assessments.
- Clearly define responsibilities in the lease document.
- Establish clear communication protocols for reporting and managing repairs.
- Review maintenance history for older buildings before signing.
- Ensure your insurance covers your maintenance obligations.
3. Breaking Commercial Leases: Rights and Consequences
Sometimes business circumstances change, and tenants may need to end leases early. Breaking a lease without proper grounds can result in:
- Ongoing rent payments until a new tenant is found
- Make-good costs to restore the premises
- Re-letting expenses such as advertising and agent fees
- Legal costs related to the breach
Legal Grounds for Breaking a Lease:
- Landlord breach of obligations
- Exercising a break clause in the lease
- Mutual agreement with the landlord
- Assignment or subletting (subject to landlord approval)
- Hardship provisions, if included
Negotiating an Early Exit:
- Check your lease for break clauses or assignment rights.
- Offer a replacement tenant to improve negotiation chances.
- Consider a lease buyout by paying a lump sum to end the lease.
- Document all agreements carefully to avoid future liability.
4. Demolition and Redevelopment Clauses
Demolition clauses allow landlords to terminate leases early to demolish or redevelop premises. These can cause uncertainty, especially for tenants with significant fit-out investments.
Under the Retail Shop Leases Act, landlords must give at least six months’ notice and may have to compensate for unrecoverable fit-out costs. For other commercial leases, protections depend on the negotiated lease terms.
Protecting Your Business:
- Negotiate compensation for relocation, business disruption, and fit-out losses.
- Seek longer notice periods if six months isn’t enough.
- Include clauses requiring genuine intention to redevelop.
- Request first right of refusal for leasing in redeveloped premises.
- Research the building’s age and landlord’s redevelopment history.
5. Dispute Resolution Options in Queensland
When disputes cannot be resolved informally, several formal options are available:
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). Learn more here:
Handles retail shop lease disputes regardless of value, offering mediation before hearings. For non-retail leases, QCAT deals with claims up to $25,000.
Queensland Courts:
- Magistrates Court: disputes up to $150,000
- District Court: disputes between $150,000 and $750,000
- Supreme Court: disputes over $750,000 or complex legal issues
Court proceedings involve filing claims, defences, disclosure, mediation attempts, and trials if necessary.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Learn more here:
Many leases require mediation or arbitration before litigation. ADR offers confidentiality, control over outcomes, quicker resolution, preservation of business relationships, and lower costs.
Preventative Measures: Avoiding Lease Disputes
The best way to handle lease disputes is to prevent them:
1. Due Diligence Before Signing:
- Check landlord reputation and financial stability
- Review building history and compliance
- Understand local development plans
- Consider your business’s future growth or contraction
- Review body corporate documents for strata properties
2. Professional Lease Review:
Always have a solicitor experienced in Queensland commercial leases review your lease, focusing on:
- Rent review mechanisms
- Use and exclusivity clauses
- Maintenance and repair obligations
- Insurance requirements
- Assignment and subletting provisions
- Default and remedy terms
- Dispute resolution procedures
3. Clear Communication Protocols:
- Document key discussions in writing
- Report maintenance issues promptly
- Provide notices as required
- Keep records of all lease communications
- Conduct regular inspections and document conditions
Conclusion
Commercial lease disputes can seriously threaten Queensland small businesses. By understanding common issues, knowing your rights under Queensland law, and adopting preventative strategies, you can reduce the risk of costly disputes. If disputes do occur, a practical, business-focused approach, whether through negotiation, mediation, or legal proceedings—will achieve the best outcomes.
At Bennett Carroll Solicitors, our experienced commercial leasing lawyers provide tailored advice suited to Queensland’s unique leasing landscape and your business needs. Contact us to understand your rights and navigate lease issues with confidence.
Why Get Legal Advice on Lease Disputes?
-
Prevent problems early: Lawyers can review leases before you sign to avoid unfair terms and future disputes.
-
Know your rights: Retail and commercial leases fall under different rules in Queensland. A lawyer makes sure you understand your protections.
-
Save time and money: Early advice often resolves disputes quickly through negotiation or mediation, before costs spiral.
-
Protect your business: Legal support helps keep your premises secure and your operations running during disputes.
Ready to Get Started?
Let’s talk about your business. Whether it’s a contract, lease, dispute or transaction, we’ll provide cost-effective, commercially sound legal advice, wherever you are in Queensland.
Contact us now or use the live chat below
Call 1300 334 566
Email here
We are your Legal Problem Solvers – helping Queensland businesses grow, comply, and succeed.
Other Useful Reads:
Commercial Lease Risk Assessment: Identifying Red Flags & Legal Tips Before You Sign
Is Your Current Lawyer Truly Supporting Your Business Goals?
Maximising Lease and Franchise Agreement Renewals: A Comprehensive Guide
